Our cappuccinos don’t build the business. Our elaborate Banana Bread Lattes do. Here’s how to design the drink people drive across the island for, and why it’s worth more than any ad.
$0spent on advertising
Millionsof views on posts of our shop and drinks
~16,000Banana Bread Lattes in 11 months
~$128Kfrom one drink, about a fifth of year one
From Courtney
We’ve never spent a dollar on advertising. Not one. And the photos and videos people have posted of our shop and our drinks have millions of views.
That didn’t happen by accident. I designed the drinks the same way I designed the room: so people would want to take a photo before they take a sip. When a customer posts your drink, it’s an ad you didn’t pay for, from someone their friends actually trust.
The Banana Bread LatteStrawberry matcha, layeredIced matcha with cold foamA sparkling special
1
A drink worth the photo
Layers, a cream top, a garnish, a color. Something that looks like nothing else on their feed.
2
A room worth the video
The design chapter covers this. The drink and the room sell each other.
3
A story worth repeating
“The banana bread latte place in Kailua.” If people can say it in one sentence, they will.
The Well’s real numbers
Margin vs. magnetism
On paper, a cappuccino has the better margin. But nobody drives across the island for a cappuccino.
From Courtney
Our menu came together days before we opened. The cream-top trend was everywhere, and banana bread lattes were having a moment in Hawai‘i, so I built ours from my own banana bread: caramelized bananas, brown sugar, maple, cinnamon, vanilla and a cream top.
Not everyone loved it, and we’ve had our critics. About 16,000 cups later, it’s the drink people drive across the island for.
The classic
Cappuccino
Price$5.00
Ingredients$0.94 (19%)
Why people come for itThey already wanted coffee
Posted?Rarely
Every café needs it dialed in. It keeps regulars happy. It won’t make you known.
Same labor either way. A barista spends about the same time on either drink, so the signature’s higher price mostly lands in your pocket.
The signature
Banana Bread Latte
Price$8.00
Ingredients$2.42 (30%)
Sold in 11 months~16,000 cups
Sales~$128,000
Kept per cup, before the loan~$2.49 (latte: $2.07)
Caramelized bananas, brown sugar, maple, cinnamon, vanilla and a cream top. It brought people in, made the menu worth photographing, and opened the door to a canned version.
✓
One of our suppliers said it best: “the iced vanilla latte pays the bills.” True. But the signature is what gets people through the door to order it.
Design a drink people want to shoot
The photo earns attention. Consistency and flavor earn the repeat visit. You need both.
A garnish that photographsA dusting on the cream topColor in layers
1
Start from a flavor people already love
Ours started from my own banana bread recipe and a trend we saw coming in Hawai‘i. Familiar flavor, new format.
2
Give it a visual signature
A cream top, a layer, a dusting, a color. Something recognizable in a two-inch thumbnail.
3
Build it from what’s on your shelf
One new ingredient at most. Every extra SKU is inventory, training and waste.
4
Make it repeatable in a rush
Write the spec, batch the syrup, and test it on your slowest barista during your busiest hour.
5
Price it to carry its weight
Run it through the calculator in the menu chapter. A signature can run a thinner margin because of the volume and the attention it brings.
6
Name it so people can say it
Short, specific and easy to tell a friend about.
Interactive
Will your signature carry the brand?
Score your idea against the same test our Banana Bread Latte passed.
Your score
0 / 7
Check each statement that’s true for your drink.
What works for us
Let your customers do the marketing
You don’t need an ad budget. You need things worth posting, and a habit of noticing when people post them.
TikTok for reach
Lo-fi and real
Drinks being made, the room in the morning light, the build-out. Real videos find new people.
Instagram for trust
Polished and consistent
The feed people check before they visit. It reassures them the place is real and worth the drive.
Repost
Share what customers post
Reposting tells everyone else that posting gets seen. It’s free content and free goodwill.
Rotate
Give them something new
A seasonal drink gives regulars a reason to come back and post again. See the seasonal plan in the menu chapter.
1:1 Consulting
Build your signature with me
Recipe building and brand are the parts of this I love most. In consulting we develop your signature drink, cost it, and design the look around it.