The Real-World Café Guide · Chapter 06

Menu creation + pricing

How to build a tight menu, cost every drink before it launches, and price it so every cup actually makes money. Built from our real supplier invoices.

12–15drinks on a strong starting menu
25–30%target ingredient cost on specialty drinks
$3.93true cost of our $6 latte
16,000Banana Bread Lattes sold in 11 months
The Well’s real numbers

Where every dollar of a drink actually goes

Ingredients are the number everyone checks. Labor, rent and fees are the ones that decide whether a cup makes money.

Labor is the same per drink, whichever drink it is. Occupancy and overhead are shown as a share of each sale, from our 2026 monthly averages. The loan line is our revenue-based financing, repaid as 10.48% of sales.

✓
Classics are your margin engine. Cortados and cappuccinos run 15–19% ingredient cost. Every café needs them dialed in.
!
Labor costs the same either way. A barista’s time is the same whether they make a latte or a Banana Bread Latte, so most of the extra $2 flows through. The signature keeps about $2.49 a cup before the loan, vs. $2.07 for a latte, and people drive across the island for it.

Line by line

Real
Cost per 16 oz drinkLatteBanana Bread Latte
Menu price$6.00$8.00
Espresso (20 g double, $0.032/g)$0.64$0.64
Whole milk (~10 oz, $0.05/oz)$0.51$0.51
Syrups, brown sugar shot, cold foam, cinnamon—$1.27
Cup, lid, straw$0.35$0.35
Card processing (3.55%)$0.21$0.28
Labor (same barista time per drink)$1.50$1.50
Rent, CAM and GET (~7%)$0.42$0.56
Electric, internet, insurance, POS (~5%)$0.30$0.40
True cost$3.93$5.51
Profit before loan$2.07 (35%)$2.49 (31%)
After loan withholding (10.48%)$1.44$1.65
Upgrade

The New Hire Manual Builder

Turn these specs into training your team actually follows. Build your own manual from our templates.

  • Drink spec cards for every item on your menu
  • Opening, closing and cleaning schedules
  • Scheduling and labor templates
  • Onboarding checklist and first-week plan
Add the manual builder

[Price to set]